Who is Israel?
Is Israel a land? A people? A religion? A modern nation-state? A spiritual identity? Purely an ethnicity? Before we attempt to answer, we need to acknowledge something important (and maybe even obvious): this is a complex question!
It’s Not As Simple As It Seems
“Who is Israel?”
At first, this feels like an easy question. It’s a nation…or a people. But then the follow-up question comes:
“Who is a Jew?”
Is it a religion? If so, what about secular Jewish people who are not religious…and those who don’t even believe in God?
The moment you start digging, it becomes clear that these questions are anything but simple.
Between the two of us, we know a lot of Jewish people. We realize that if we invited ten Jewish people into a room and asked them to define Jewish identity, we would likely get at least ten different answers. In fact, there’s an old saying: “Ask two Jews, you’ll get three opinions.” And honestly, that’s not far from the truth.
Is Israel a land? A people? A religion? A modern nation-state? A spiritual identity? Purely an ethnicity? Before we attempt to answer, we need to acknowledge something important (and maybe even obvious): this is a complex question!
The answer we are about to give you is clearly biblical, but it’s not the only way people will respond to this question. Someone somewhere will disagree. But this framework will help clarify what the Bible has to say.
From Hebrew to Israelite
If you follow the progression of scripture, you will see that Abraham is the first to be called a Hebrew, which likely means someone “who crossed over.” (Genesis 14:13) God makes an everlasting covenant with Abraham and then reaffirms that covenant with Abraham’s son, Isaac, and then Isaac’s son, Jacob.
But everything shifts when Abraham’s grandson Jacob encounters God and is given a new name: Israel. (Genesis 32:28) From that moment forward, his descendants are no longer just Hebrews; they are primarily referred to as “the children of Israel.”
As they multiplied in Egypt, they were also known as the sons of Israel:
Exodus 1:7 ESV
But the people of Israel were fruitful and increased greatly…
From Israelite to Jew
This Israelite identity continued for hundreds of years, up to and including the united tribal kingdom under David and Solomon. But when the kingdom fell into division, the ten northern tribes retained the name Israel, and the southern kingdom became known as Judah. Over time, the term “Jew” (Yehudi) emerged from that kingdom (2 Kings 16:6).
However, Scripture shows that Judah was no longer a single tribe, but a people from all the tribes:
2 Chronicles 11:16 ESV
Those from all the tribes of Israel… came to Jerusalem (in Judah) to seek the Lord.
When the Judah was taken captive into Babylon, they continued to be called Jews (Esther 2:5; Daniel 3:12). When they returned to the Land, the name endured. This was because Judah had become a refuge for the entire faithful remnant of Israel before and after Babylon.
A New Testament example of this is Anna the Prophetess, mentioned as one who spent most of her time in the Temple. When Jesus’s parents brought Him to be dedicated, Anna “of the tribe of Asher” (Luke 2:36) was there, living in Jerusalem among the Jews, and was a witness that God had not forgotten His people. Her very presence demonstrated that His covenant remained alive amongst all of Israel.
God promised through the Prophets that in the end times the “Root of Jesse” would gather the “outcasts of Israel” from all the nations (Isaiah 11:12) and give them a new spirit and a new heart (Ezekiel 36:24–28). In other words, the other ten northern tribes have never been “lost” to God and will be part of the great restoration of Israel in the future.
So… What Makes Someone Jewish?
Here’s a simple way to understand Jewish identity. Think of a three-strand rope. The three strands represent land, lineage, and covenantal living. In some ways, this is an oversimplification, but it may help you grasp the unique elements that make up Jewish distinctiveness.
People will ask, is being Jewish a religion or an ethnicity? The answer is both. Israel is not just one or the other but is a covenant people. God did not choose Israel just to preserve a bloodline, but to preserve a testimony to His faithfulness in human history.
For this reason, Jewish identity cannot be reduced to sociology alone. It includes ancestry, memory, covenant, responsibility, and the call to sanctify the Name of the God of Israel in the world.
1. Lineage
The easiest of these three elements to explain is lineage. While the debate can get quite complex given the modern return to Israel, in its simplest form, a Jew is a physical descendant of Jacob. Because Israel was scattered from their homeland during the Diaspora, Jewish communities can be found all over the globe. A Jewish person is a Jew whether they live inside or outside of Israel. Some may not be religious or even believe in God, yet they remain Jewish by lineage.
2. Land
The land of Israel is nearly inseparable from the people of Israel, primarily because the people and the land are mentioned in tandem throughout the Bible. As we said, Jews can live as Jews outside of Israel, but the land is always a critical piece of their identity puzzle.
God took Abraham out of the nations to start a new family and made a two-fold covenant with him:
I will make you a people, a great nation, descendants as numerous as the stars.
I will give you and your descendants the land of Canaan (biblical and modern-day Israel).
Genesis 13:14–15 ESV
The LORD said to Abram, ”Lift up your eyes and look from the place where you are… for all the land that you see I will give to you and to your offspring forever.”
Genesis 17:8 ESV
“I will give to you and to your offspring… all the land of Canaan, for an everlasting possession.”
An incredible scene takes place in Genesis 15 when God Himself makes this covenant with Abraham. A pillar of fire (representing the presence of God) passes through the animals that had been sacrificed. Some realize this is a foreshadowing of not only the Passover sacrifice, but also the Gospel when Jesus, as the Perfect Sacrifice, shed His own blood for our redemption. Yet, many Christian readers forget that this covenant is literally about God giving the described land to Abraham and his children forever.
Genesis 15:17-18 ESV
There appeared a smoking oven and a flaming torch which passed between these pieces. On that day, the LORD made a covenant with Abram, saying, “To your descendants I have given this land, From the river of Egypt as far as the great river, the river Euphrates…”
The promise of the land to Israel is unconditional and will always remain a promised inheritance. However, God states later in Deuteronomy that the possession of the land is conditional, based upon Israel’s obedience.
That is why Eretz Israel (the Land of Israel) is bound to covenant, memory, and mission. The land is the inheritance. It reminds Israel who she is, before Whom she stands, and for what purpose she continues to exist in history.
Even when the Jewish people were separated from their land, it was only a physical separation, not spiritual. For almost 2,000 years, the Jewish people prayed three times a day facing towards Jerusalem. Every year on Passover, they ended the feast by saying “Next year in Jerusalem.” When the Jewish people were scattered during the Diaspora across Europe, Africa, and the Middle East, they kept the same holidays associated with the different harvest seasons of the Land of Israel.
Today, we have seen the regathering of the people of Israel to their promised land. It’s a modern-day miracle and fulfillment of prophecy before our very eyes. Jews are once again being born inside the borders of Israel. They may be secular or atheists in belief, but they are in the land and of the lineage of Jacob – and they are Jewish.
Many ask, “If you are born in Israel, does that make you Jewish?” This is a normal conclusion in nations such as America, where birthright citizenship makes you an American. But Jews are a people, a land, and a covenant (or a faith). While it makes you Israeli, it doesn’t make you Jewish.
There are approximately two million people of Arab ethnicity who are citizens of Israel. Their children are born in Israel, but they are not Jewish; they are Arab Israelis with equal citizenship and equal rights. Many serve in the IDF, and even hold the highest offices in the Israeli government. Religiously, most Israeli Arabs are Muslim, but there are Israeli Arab Christians, too. This should put to bed the idea that Israel is an apartheid state because it’s categorically not true.
3. Covenantal Living
Many books have been written about this subject but basically it is about “living out” the covenant God gave to Israel. In certain streams of Judaism, this could be as simple as loving God, keeping Shabbat, and being circumcised. In others, it is keeping every commandment of the Torah and teachings of the rabbis (Talmud). Although many would disagree on HOW to live a covenantal life, most would agree that it is part of what makes up Jewish distinction.
Covenantal living is an important identity factor because we tend to forget about those who have converted to Judaism. Unlike Christianity, Judaism does not proselytize or seek religious converts. Conversion is offered, mostly within the confines of marriage — or to the few who desire to yoke themselves to the people of Israel. This idea is deeply entrenched in the scriptures. We see Gentiles, like Ruth and Rahab, who chose to convert and cling to the God of Israel. They both ended up as part of the genealogy of Jesus.
This brings up another interesting fact. Even in the strictest streams of Judaism, a Gentile who has undergone a conversion process is NEVER looked at as anything but a Jew for the rest of his or her life. A Jewish convert is not a second-class citizen and is in no way any less of a Jew than a natural-born descendant of Jacob. This is important for us to understand. If someone says, “just take a DNA test to prove your Jewishness,” that will only work for people with a physical lineage. It does not take into consideration the years of intermarriage or chosen conversion others may have experienced—like Ruth and Rahab.
The Modern Debate
In the modern era, the question of “Who is a Jew?” has become even more complex and deeply debated. During the Holocaust, Adolf Hitler defined Jewish identity by ancestry and may have been the first one to categorize “Jewish” as a race. Hitler’s definition applied to anyone having one or more Jewish parents or grandparents, meaning people were persecuted and killed regardless of personal belief or practice. The Nazis even demanded the churches’ baptism records to help hunt down Jewish followers of Jesus.
In response, the modern State of Israel adopted a similar framework for aliyah (immigration) through the Law of Return. This offered refuge to anyone who would have been considered Jewish under Nazi definition. So today, if you have a Jewish parent or grandparent, in theory, you can immigrate to Israel.
All this has created ongoing tension, as religious (halachic), ethnic, and national definitions of Jewishness do not always agree. There have been many Messianic Jews, for instance, even children or grandchildren of Holocaust survivors, who have been denied Israeli citizenship because they follow Yeshua and are deemed “no longer Jewish.”
For the Jewish disciple of Yeshua, this is one of the great ironies of history. A Jew does not cease to be a Jew for believing that another Jew is the Messiah of Israel. The first disciples, the apostles, the family of Yeshua, and the thousands of believers in Jerusalem were all Jews, zealous for the God of their fathers and rooted in the life of their people.
For a Jew, faith in Yeshua should not erase Jewish identity. Rather, it confirms the hope of Israel. Denying the Jewish identity of a Jewish believer is a verdict that finds no support in Scripture. Tragically, throughout both Church and rabbinic history, many have tried to erase Jewish distinction within the body of the Messiah.
There is much more that could be said about Jewish identity, but you can see it’s not a settled matter. The question remains an active and sometimes contested conversation within Israel and the global Jewish community. With this understanding, we can move forward in this devotional with greater clarity about who Israel is—not as an abstract idea, but as a people shaped by land, lineage, and covenant.
So, with this foundation in place, let’s now turn our attention to the next important question: “Who is the Church?
In Closing
There’s not a one-line answer for “Who is a Jew?” But maybe that’s the point because Israel has always been:
A person
A people
And a promised Land
Through the story of Israel, if you listen closely, God is revealing His heart to the world.
Prayer
Lord, thank You for the clarity of Your Word, even amid complexity. Help us understand Israel as You define it, not through assumptions but through Scripture. Guard our hearts from oversimplifying what You have made rich and layered. Teach us to honor Your faithfulness to Israel while fully embracing the invitation You’ve extended to the Nations — to be grafted into Israel’s promises. Align our hearts with Yours, full of truth, humility, and love.
In Jesus’s name, Amen.